Homemade Creme Eggs {Paleo, Nut Free}

These homemade copycat Cadbury Creme Eggs are a rich and decadent paleo chocolate treat that everyone will love!  Easy to make – the filling comes together in just a few minutes and contains no nuts or refined sugar, and has a dairy free option. 

This recipe was born out of pure curiosity – is it even remotely possible to create a “clean(er)” version of the the almighty Cadbury Creme Egg?

I seriously had my doubts, until I started doing a little “research” (AKA googling recipes) and discovered that I could probably swing a technically paleo version of these bad boys that would actually be acceptable to Cadbury loving kids and adults alike.

Look, I’m not about to call these treats “healthy”, however they ARE made completely without any corn syrup, or refined sugar at all for that matter.  That said, I used a whole lot of unrefined sugar to make this recipe, so, be warned – a sweet tooth is necessary for this one!

My kids had a minor problem with the fact that the cream center is, well, cream colored rather than layered yellow and white.

Truth be told – with a bit more effort you CAN make the yellow inside – by dividing the filling and coloring half of it with a bit of turmeric, then wrapping the light color around a little ball of the yellow.

However, I honestly had no desire to do this for myself, and, according to my informal Instagram poll a week ago, the great majority are in it for the taste rather than the yellow inside.  Even so, my kids stressed me out a little bit about this decision, but, ultimately I felt like I didn’t need turmeric in my creme eggs 🙂

I remember WAY back when, before ever actually trying a Cadbury creme egg, seeing those glorious commercials where they break one apart and you seeing that dreamy, stretchy creamy center with the milk chocolate outside. I just KNEW it had to be the most incredible dessert on the planet, from that commercial alone.

What they actually are is one of the most sickeningly sweet desserts on the planet, in my opinion.  So much so, that I couldn’t even bring myself to try a real one for testing’s sake.  However, my kids happily took over that job, and in the spirit of full disclosure, here is their report:

1.) The originals are sweeter overall and the filling stretchier and gooier (although my filling stretches!  yay!)

2.) My version kind of tastes like honey (because I used honey)

3.) My version is good enough to sneak some upstairs and blame a sibling

4.) My version has better chocolate (score for dark!)

5.) But can we still finish the package of the originals?!

So, there you have it.  Here’s the breakdown of what I did.  I created my own version of powdered sugar by putting maple sugar (for the light color) and arrowroot starch in my food processor and blending until as powdery as I could get it.

Yes, it’s a bit grittier than actual confectioner sugar, but, this didn’t bother me.  If you don’t mind using organic confectioner sugar, that’s another option in place of the maple/arrowroot.

I then blended grass-fed butter (ghee or palm shortening are good too) with raw honey until very smooth, added vanilla, salt, and the processed maple/arrowroot combo.  I chilled the mixture for a little while so I could scoop it and roll it easily.  It really couldn’t be easier and hey – no cooking necessary!

If you’re looking for a cleaner version of this classic treat, you’re definitely in for a real, well, treat!  I’m excited for you to try these – let’s go!

Homemade Creme Eggs {Paleo, Nut Free}

Homemade Creme Eggs {Paleo, Nut Free}

These homemade copycat Cadbury Creme Eggs are a rich and decadent paleo chocolate treat that everyone will love!  Easy to make - the filling comes together in just a few minutes and contains no nuts or refined sugar, and has a dairy free option. 

Author: Michele Rosen

Prep Time: 10 minutes

Cook Time: 1 minute

setting time: 30 mins

Total Time: 11 minutes

Course: Dessert

Cuisine: Paleo

Servings: 16 creme eggs

Print this Recipe

Did you make this recipe?

Leave a review

4.41 from 10 votes

Ingredients

Cream Filling:

• 1/4 cup softened grass fed butter ghee or palm oil shortening (room temp)
• 1/2 cup raw honey use one that’s light in color
• 1 tsp pure vanilla extract
• 1 cup maple sugar or organic cane sugar
• 1/4 cup arrowroot starch
• 1/8 tsp salt

Chocolate Option 1:

• 9 oz Hu Kitchen Gems or dark chocolate chips
• 1 tsp coconut oil

Chocolate Option 2 (Homemade):

• Use this recipe (originally for my truffles)

Instructions

Prepare Filling:

1. Place sugar and arrowroot starch in a food processor or blender and blend until a powdery texture forms, (this takes about 2 mins) then set aside

2. Using an electric hand mixer, blend butter or shortening with honey, vanilla and salt in a large bowl until very smooth.

3. Blend in the sugar/starch mixture until smooth, then place in the refrigerator or freezer to set for about 20-30 mins.
4. Meanwhile, prepare the chocolate mixture. You have 2 options to make the chocolate: using dark chocolate chips or making your own chocolate.

Chocolate Option 1:

1. In a microwave safe bowl melt the chocolate chips or Gems and coconut oil on high heat, removing to stir every 30 seconds until melted and smooth. You can also do this in a small saucepan over very low heat.

Chocolate Option 2:

1. Follow this recipe (originally for my truffles)

Assemble Creme Eggs:

1. After preparing chocolate, use a spoon to swirl some all around the egg molds to completely coat bottom and sides, then freeze until set - about 5 mins.

2. Once chocolate is set, spoon the filling by 1 1/2 tsp (or to fill your mold) and roll into an egg shape, place over the chocolate and flatten a bit (as shown in the photo)

3. When all molds are filled, spoon remaining chocolate over the filling for each egg. Return to the freezer to set - this time about 15 mins.

4. Once set, your creme eggs can be stored in the refrigerator to avoid any melting. Prior to serving, you can let them sit out a bit so the chocolate softens a little.
5. Enjoy!

Nutrition

Calories: 160kcal

Carbohydrates: 21g

Protein: 1g

Fat: 8g

Saturated Fat: 6g

Cholesterol: 7mg

Sodium: 61mg

Potassium: 111mg

Sugar: 15g

Vitamin A: 90IU

Vitamin C: 0.2mg

Calcium: 52mg

Iron: 0.3mg

Did you make this recipe?

Tag @PaleoRunningMomma on Instagram and hashtag it #PaleoRunningMomma

What I Used To Make My Homemade Creme Eggs:

Want more Paleo friendly chocolate treats?  Try one of these!

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Truffles {Vegan}

Almond Butter Chocolate Fudge

Paleo and Vegan Chocolate Pudding {Nut Free}

Chocolate Frosted Chocolate Donuts  {Nut Free}

Homemade Coconut Butter Cups {Vegan}

Note: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and make a purchase, I will receive a small commission at no cost to you. Thank you for supporting Paleo Running Momma!